Real School Choice vs inter-district transfers
A way around the DC vouchers impasse is proposed. The Democrats in Congress and Obama administration cut funding for a voucher program to rescue kids from the failing DC school system. The DC public schools are extremely expensive (average cost of $14,000 per year), but have a terrible performance record. The author proposes inter-district transfer program, to bus DC kids to suburban school. Some comments on that:
"Both transfer and charter school models bring some more opportunity, but remain very limited in relinquishing real power to parents and families."
I'm not saying these choice systems should go away. They are definitely needed today. I guess my main point is that they do not go nearly far enough in fundamentally changing the way we deliver education."
"Neither model provides the kind of system change, and power reallocation, needed for transformation. "I agree. Go ahead and do this inter-district transfer thing, but lets not pretend its the real answer. It's a band aid.
After all, someone in the inner city DC should not to have to send their kids over 12 miles and an hour-plus bus drive away to high school just to get a decent education.If the DC public schools are doing an abysmal job (and they are), quit propping up and rewarding failure and abuse of kids. the entire school system should be dissolved and replaced with a voucher-based school choice system, and let each school be run by parents,teachers groups or other private organizations, and let them work to attract students by creating real learning in their schools.
The Century Foundation could lead the way by taking over some of the schools and using their best thoughts to run them. If the Foundation is not willing to pitch in, then they really are of no help.
Further comments: