Showing posts with label education issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education issues. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Abstinence Sex Ed Superior to "comprehensive"

Study comparing abstinence sex ed and 'comprehensive' sex ed shows abstinence winning 36% to 25% on a key metric:

IRE then analyzed these school-based programs according to what it considered to be more meaningfulstandards of effectiveness:
1) Did the program increase teen abstinence or consistent condom use?
2) Did this behavior change occur for the target population and not just for a subgroup of students?
3) Did the effect last at least one year, that is, from one school year to the next?
Applying these criteria, IRE found that a higher percent of school-based abstinence programs were effective than CSE programs: 36% vs. 25%.
This review contradicts recent claims made in Time, Newsweek, and a Congressional letter circulated by Rep. Paul Hodes (D-New Hampshire) that abstinence education has failed while comprehensive sexeducation has been successful. Dr. Weed expressed surprise that the lack of evidence of CSE success in schools had not been reported: “Research evidence does not support the widespread distribution of comprehensive sex education in the schools or the elimination of abstinence education as a viable
prevention strategy.”

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Texas Senate Democrats block McLeroy for SBOE Chairman

Democrats Block McLeroy. The vote was 19-11 on a party-line vote; McLeroy required 2/3rds or 21 votes to be confirmed. The Democrats blocked Dr McLeroy because his Christian beliefs and his actions over science standards had aroused opposition from liberal interest groups, including Planned Parenthood, who testified against McLeroy during his rocky reception at Texas Senate hearings.

Free Market Foundation (FMF) Director of Legislative Affairs and Attorney Jonathan Saenz released the following statement: “Some Senators have made it clear that the N.Y. Times, religious beliefs, and party affiliation are in control of deciding who serves as SBOE chairman. The message has been sent — if you have sincere religious beliefs, you need not apply to be chair of the State Board of Education.”
Sen Kirk Watson had an interesting quote: “He has enthusiastically embraced his role in the endless cultural wars,” ... Really? What about the other side of the battlefield? Did not Sen Kirk Watson enthusiastically embrace his role as a warrior on the other side by questioning Dr McLeroy's capability and voting him out as SBOE Chairman?

Sen. Leticia Van de Putte, D-San Antonio, said “The state board has become increasingly divided and deeply dysfunctional and almost paralyzed to action at certain times,” . ... Really? As with Sen Watson's quote on 'cultural wars', it takes two to tango. If SBOE is 'paralyzed' then why are there efforts to reduce SBOE power instead of maintain and increase it? McLeroy’s leadership was shown when he led the board to the nearly unanimous vote of 13-2 on the new science standards to continue to allow discussion and debate on critical science issues, including evolution. Some amendments had votes of 8-7. (Do we call the Supreme Court or the Texas Senate paralyzed because the body isn't always unanimous? Should House Speaker Strauss be fired because Dunham D's blew up and paralyzed the House this week?)

Maybe SBOE got divided because the people are divided on this issue and various interest groups are as well. Creationists want a chance to not have kids taught that evolution is the one and only truth of the matter; evolutionists don't want science and 'pseudo-science' mixed. The news headlines that came out of that new science standard was: Teaching evolution now protected. It's a decent compromise that takes keeps evolution in textbooks, does not force 'weaknesses' of evolution to be taught, but encourages examining scientific theories via critical thinking:

“The requirement that students examine, ‘analyze, evaluate and critique scientific explanations' and examine all sides of scientific evidence is the strongest critical thinking standard in any state science standards,” said Casey Luskin, a lawyer for the Seattle-based Discovery Institute ... Texans Citizens for Science President Steven Schafersman said “I think the science standards will be OK. Frankly, the publishers and the authors of the textbooks will be able to use this standard and write good textbooks,”
So surely this is not a reaction to the (reasonable science) standards that were produced by the SBOE. What then? Blaming Dr McLeroy for the 'cultural wars' that are engaged by the partisans already, then dumping on him because people are divided on issues is the height of irony. It's real simple: The Texas Senate Democrats dumped on Christian conservative Dr McLeroy not for being ineffective, but for working for things that ticked off the liberal interest groups that opposed him all along. One can replace "SBOE" for "Dr McLeroy" and the truth is the same. Now why can't Sen Kirk Watson admit that?

Monday, July 28, 2008

Terri Leo: State Board of Education Update

Dallas Morning News Editorial Board Blunders Again (July 27, 2008)

When the Dallas Morning News editorial board in today's commentary proclaimed the virtues of the New Jersey Writing Project as a way to improve students' abilities to write, the Board showed its utter ignorance of what really goes on in Texas' public schools.

For over twenty years, almost every English teacher in Texas has followed the New Jersey Writing Project's philosophy of teaching writing! During those twenty years, school districts have paid huge amounts of tax dollars for teachers to be completely brainwashed in NJWP. What do we have to show for it? We have the type of students who cannot write a substantive, well-written, short-answer response on the TAKS tests; nor can students write the type of sophisticated papers that are needed in college and in the workplace. Ironically, this was the subject of Laurie Fox's and Holly Hacker's article to which the editorial board refers.

What the editorial board should have done was to applaud the efforts of the majority of the Texas State Board of Education members who on 5.23.08 dramatically changed the direction of our public schools away from the NJWP's wrong-headed curriculum.

The SBOE set our public schools on a new path toward the direct and systematic teaching of grammar, usage, capitalization, punctuation, spelling, and handwriting as basic skills that form the foundation of good writing. Students cannot apply what they do not know. They cannot write well until they first learn how the English language is constructed.

Starting this fall, all Texas English teachers will begin the transition into the new standards (TEKS); and by next school year, these standards will be implemented with students, K-12.

A new day is coming for our Texas school students, and the DMN editorial board members need to find out what is happening before they commit further embarrassing blunders. -- Donna Garner

Editorial: Texas must improve student writing

12:00 AM CDT on Sunday, July 27, 2008

Here's the question about standardized tests: Can students prepare for them and still learn to think conceptually, including how to write persuasively?

The answer is yes, absolutely, but the effort will require teachers being devoted to teaching students to think creatively and to mastering material for a test.

Dallas Morning News reporters Laurie Fox and Holly Hacker explored this issue last Sunday in a probing report into how some North Texas high schoolers are flunking the short-essay part of the Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills for language arts. Not even half pass this portion, which requires reading a short piece and responding to it in a clear, thoughtful way.

Some blame excessive testing, but testing isn't the problem. If not for the test, we wouldn't know how bad the problem is.

The problem is students aren't sufficiently learning writing skills before high school. This spring, results from the gold standard of tests, the National Assessment of Educational Progress, showed that 74 percent of Texas eighth-graders – three out of four, on average – write below grade level.

Good writing requires students to think critically, set up an argument and present it artfully. And it can be part of any district's curriculum, if made a priority.
Just for the Kids, an Austin-based group that tracks best practices across the nation, praises several districts for their writing strategies. For example, Weslaco, Texas, schools use the New Jersey Writing Project that outlines ways to teach writing and establishes clear expectations.

Turning this problem around will require that superintendents insist on strong writing exercises – and more testing of writing skills. Texas only assesses short-response writing skills in high school on the English language exam. Missouri, Connecticut and other states test writing in more grades and subjects, including math.

Additional testing will require more state dollars for the Texas Education Agency. Written exams, after all, require humans – not computers – to evaluate them.
But the extra expenditures should even out over time. Colleges certainly wouldn't have to spend so much in remedial writing classes. And students would learn a skill they will need in a world that still prizes communication.